Why Hangboarding Isn't Making Your Hands Stronger
What if I told you that your obsession with getting stronger hands is one of the reasons you’re struggling to improve?
Almost everything we do in climbing involves grip to some degree. On one hand, this means that stronger and fitter hands have great carryover to climbing performance. On the other hand, it means it’s very easy to overtax our fingers without realizing it. If everything you do is a finger workout, then when do your hands get a chance to recover?
I can’t count the number of times I’ve talked with someone who was convinced their poor results from finger strength training were from: A) Bad genetics, B) Having a high training age, or C) Not having found the “perfect” training protocol yet, only for the truth to be that they are trying to do more in a week than their body can sufficiently recover from.
I believe this is the primary reason people struggle to get great results from repeater hangboard protocols. These protocols (such as Will Anglin’s 6&10 workout, which I highly recommend), require far more recovery than a handful of max hangs. While repeaters are an amazing tool for developing high-level hand strength, many people don’t allow for enough recovery from session to session to see results.
This is why you see so many climbers put in a tremendous amount of time and effort into their climbing and training, and still struggle to get stronger. Their body is doing everything it can just to recover from the workouts and return to baseline. They don’t have enough recovery time to get stronger.
If this sounds like you, you have two options. First, work to improve your recovery. If you can recover better then you’ll get more out of your current methods. The two best ways to do this are to get better sleep and to eat like an athlete. If you can learn to regularly sleep well and sufficiently fuel yourself for your workouts, you’ll be amazed at how much quality work you’re capable of.
The second option is to look for redundancy in your weekly schedule. If you’re board climbing, hangboarding, limit bouldering, projecting, doing recruitment hangs, no-hangs, working on your “lazy fingers”, and adding in supplemental wrist work, ALL of those things are directly taxing your forearms and will cancel each other out at a certain point.
I don’t know your situation so it’s impossible for me to give a blanket statement as to whether you are doing too much currently. But if you feel like you’re working hard and doing all the “right things” without seeing much payoff, then it’s worth making some changes and seeing if the problem is that your hands are constantly under-recovered.
If you have no clue what to change in your program or just want a fresh starting point, a good place to look would be the training plans that we offer.
We know spending time on a finishing link is smart tactics for hard climbs. So why not apply the same concept to individual moves?
Learning when and how to compensate for a weakness is a skill. And skills need to be practiced.
Lowball boulders, while not as proud, can still teach us new movement, new ways to utilize tension, and force us into finding new techniques.
I never thought I’d be recommending this, but some of y’all should be putting less effort into becoming technically better climbers.
Training principles are important, but when they creep into performance, your climbing will suffer. Nearly every time.
We have become collectors of dots. But there’s one major thing that happens when we connect dots that is entirely lost in mass dot collection: critical thinking.
Do you really have terrible willpower? Or are you surrounded by distractions and obstacles?
You have a climbing trip coming up. The rock is different. The style is different. Your pre-trip time is short and the number of days you’ll be climbing, even shorter…
Giving artificially low grades to climbs increases their perceived value for our training and development. The more something is mis-graded the more we naturally want to prioritize it.
Discussion around grades can be so polarizing that many of us avoid the topic.
Climbing starts off as this self-feeding cycle that has you wishing you could climb seven days a week. What happens when this cycle stops bringing improvement though?
Look, it’s important to not let things get overcomplicated. Hunting for elegant answers keeps us from getting bogged down with minutia. But when we take it too far, we lose sight of the bigger picture.
Use strength to leverage every other aspect of your climbing, not replace them.
If everything you do is a finger workout, then when do your hands get a chance to recover?
There is a common theme between a grilled cheese sandwich and good training advice.
The more accurately we define our problems, the more approachable it will feel to find solutions.
Maybe the most understated way of getting better is to build fallback successes into your plan.
How much time should climbers spend becoming more well rounded vs. improving their strengths?
As cool as assessments and standards are, they can easily leave people settling for “good enough” when they have the potential to do much more.
Being able to quickly recognize familiar sequences is a crucial ingredient to harder climbing.
The difficulties of a task should be such that they help the learner translate the skill to performance.
It’s far more comfortable for us to blame ignorance for our lack of progress than it is to blame our own efforts.
You’re watching your client, student, partner, or bestie struggle. And you want to help. But how? It entirely depends on the goal.
We think we know exactly what climbing looks like. We’ve zeroed in on the details. And in this case, it really isn’t those details that matter.
If everything you do is a finger workout, then when do your hands get a chance to recover?
Climber performance metrics only tell a small part of a much more complex human story.
Nate provides more depth to the reasoning behind many common finger training methods.
We gathered the data. Here’s what it says about how finger and pulling strength combine for climbing performance.
One of the most common places things start to fall apart is at the very beginning of the move.